diff --git a/web/lib/recurly_client.rb b/web/lib/recurly_client.rb
index e6d0cd6f7..4992814cb 100644
--- a/web/lib/recurly_client.rb
+++ b/web/lib/recurly_client.rb
@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ module JamRuby
           raise RecurlyClientError, "Subscription not found" if paid_subscription.nil?
           raise RecurlyClientError, "Plan code '#{paid_subscription.plan_code}' doesn't match jam track: '#{jam_track.plan_code}'" if paid_subscription.plan_code != jam_track.plan_code
 
-          jam_track_right=JamRuby::JamTrackRight.find_or_initialize_by_user_id_and_jam_track_id(current_user, jam_track)                    
+          jam_track_right=JamRuby::JamTrackRight.find_or_create_by_user_id_and_jam_track_id(current_user.id, jam_track.id)                    
           raise RecurlyClientError.new("Error creating jam_track_right for jam_track: #{jam_track.id}") if jam_track_right.nil?
           raise RecurlyClientError.new(jam_track_right.errors) if jam_track_right.errors.any?                
         rescue Recurly::Error, NoMethodError => x